Adéu a Nihil Obstat | Hola a The Catalan Analyst

Després de 13 anys d'escriure en aquest bloc pràcticament sense interrumpció, avui el dono per clausurat. Això no vol dir que m'hagi jubilat de la xarxa, sinó que he passat el relleu a un altra bloc que segueix la mateixa línia del Nihil Obstat. Es tracta del bloc The Catalan Analyst i del compte de Twitter del mateix nom: @CatalanAnalyst Us recomano que els seguiu.

Moltes gràcies a tots per haver-me seguit amb tanta fidelitat durant tots aquests anys.

dijous, 27 de març del 2008

El perquè de la probable victòria de McCain

Si Barack Obama obté la nominació pel Partit Demòcrata, només el 53% dels votants de Clinton votarien per ell, el 19% votaria per McCain i el 13% es quedaria a casa. Si la nominació l’obtingués Hillary Clinton, el 60% dels votants d’Obama li donarien el vot, el 20% votaria per McCain i el 3% s’abstindria. Vet aquí perquè el republicà John McCain continua sent el favorit per ocupar la Casa Blanca que se’n vagi Bush. Les dades corresponen a una enquesta de la Franklin & Marshall College a l'estat de Pennsylvània.

(Via Johan Norberg)

I després diuen que no hi ha dues Europes!

El primer ministre de Polònia, Donald Tusk, i els presidents de Txèquia, Vaclav Klaus, i d'Estònia, Toomas Hendrik Ilves, han anunciat ja la seva intenció de no anar a les cerimònies institucionals dels Jocs Olímpics de Pequín d'aquest estiu.

Una vegada més, la nova Europa pren el relleu a la vella, que sembla incapaç de defensar, ni tant sols simbòlicament, els valors democràtics i els drets humans que li són consubstancials.

Tots es desgela, menys el cervell

Se'ls queia la baba donant la notícia: un bloc de gel d'una superfície equivalent a l'illa d'Eivissa s'ha desprès de l'Antàrtida per culpa del canvi climàtic. Antón Uriarte encara riu...
El pasado mes de Septiembre, al final del invierno austral, la extensión del hielo marino que rodea a la Antártida batió el record de extensión desde 1979, año en que los satélites comenzaron a medirla. Luego, como todos los veranos se redujo casi en su totalidad (pinchar gráfica). Hay algunas plataformas de hielo costero que aguantan la insolación veraniega. Especialmente las plataformas de Ross y de Ronne, en el mar de Wedell. Y al parecer así ocurría también con la plataforma pequeña de Wilkins.

La plataforma de Wilkins se encuentra en una zona, la Península de la Antártida, que en las últimas décadas ha sufrido, por razones de la circulación de vientos y corrientes, un calentamiento. Pero los que, aparte de periódicos y teles, consultamos internet, sabemos que el conjunto de la Antártida no se ha calentado y que el hielo marino ha seguido en los últimos años su vaivén estacional.

dimecres, 26 de març del 2008

Mentides i veritats de la guerra de l'Iraq

Un article del diplomàtic español Inocencio Arias de lectura obligatòria.
Bush fue totalmente por libre y se inventó lo de las armas de destrucción masiva para justificar la intervención. Incorrecto. En su país, Bush estaba totalmente arropado. Legalmente, 77 de 100 senadores le dieron luz verde legal. Popularmente, casi el 80% de los encuestados apoyaban la intervención. Y mediáticamente, prácticamente ningún medio repudió la intervención. Muchos analistas americanos han entonado posteriormente un mea culpa por su seguidismo. Los atentados del 11-S les habían traumatizado y cegado.

En el plano internacional, Bush no consiguió la autorización del Consejo de Seguridad de la ONU, pero sí tenía un buen número de gobiernos que lo apoyaban. No se inventó las armas de destrucción masiva. Sadam Huseim las había usado en el pasado, contra los iraníes y contra los kurdos. Además, la mayor parte de los servicios de inteligencia del mundo creían que existían; el propio Bill Clinton lo afirmó poco antes de dejar la Casa Blanca. Dirigentes que no querían la guerra, como Chirac o Mubarak, pensaban que Sadam no se había desembarazado de ellas. Las discusiones versaban sobre si se intervenía o se proseguían las inspecciones, no sobre la existencia de las armas.
(...)
Aznar se separó de la línea europea apoyando a EEUU. Harto dudoso. No había una sola línea. Había dos posturas europeas. En un lado, estaban Francia, Alemania, Suecia, Bélgica…; y en el otro, el Reino Unido, España, Italia, Portugal… Europa se partió literalmente en dos. Identificar la postura del continente con la de Francia es trasnochado e inaceptable. ¿Desde cuándo es más Europa la patria de Molière y de Kant que la de Newton, Dante y Goya? Lo cierto es que había dos Europas.
(...)
Se asegura que la retirada de las tropas españolas de Irak se realizó porque, a diferencia de lo que ocurre en Afganistán y otros lugares, su presencia era claramente ilegal. Una memez. Nuestras tropas se retirarían porque el presidente Zapatero lo había prometido en su campaña electoral. Una razón política sólida, sí; pero su presencia era totalmente legal porque tenía la bendición del Consejo de Seguridad, que es el órgano que debía darla. El Consejo, en el octubre previo a nuestras elecciones -Resolución 1511 aprobada por unanimidad- no sólo apoyaba la presencia de las tropas de la coalición en Irak, sino que instaba a los estados miembros a prestar asistencia… «incluyendo fuerzas militares» a la misma. Es decir, animaba a más países a enviar tropas.

Podeu llegir també "La guerra que Zapatero quería perder" de Rafael L. Bardají i "El futuro (de Irak) no es lo que era" de Juan F. Carmona y Choussat.

Catastrofistes i escèptics

Els recomano que facin l'esforç de llegir l'article "Los disidentes del cambio climático. Las posiciones ultraliberales dan pábulo a los escépticos del calentamiento", publicat ahir a La Vanguardia. Amb la pretensió de denunciar i posar al descobert les vergonyes inconfessables dels escèptics, l'article aconsegueix exactament el contrari del que pretén. És a dir, evidenciar la càrrega purament ideològica dels creients en aquesta nova fe que se'n diu l'escalfament global.

Per contrastar, poden comparar per exemple el pamflet anterior amb l'entrevista que fa quatre dies publicava un diari australià al biòleg Jennifer Marohasy o l'anotació del climatòleg Anton Uriarte sobre catastrofistes i escèptics.

Confirmació

Un estudi de diversos investigadors de Harvard confirma que la cobertura mediàtica sistemàticament negativa de la guerra de l'Iraq "enardeix" els terroristes. L'estudi estableix una relació directe entre les províncies iraquianes que tenen més accés a la informació internacional i l'increment de la violència insurgent, que respon en funció del que es diu i es publica als EUA.
Using data on attacks and variation in access to international news across Iraqi provinces, we identify an "emboldenment" effect by comparing the rate of insurgent attacks in areas with higher and lower access to information about U.S news after public statements critical of the war. We find in periods after a spike in war-critical statements, insurgent attacks increases by 5-10 percent. The results suggest that insurgent groups respond rationally to expected probability of US withdrawal. As such counterinsurgency should consider deterrence and incapacitation rather than simply search and destroy missions.
(Via Extrême-Centre)

dimarts, 25 de març del 2008

El cost real de la immigració

S'ha publicat a França un estudi que trenca alguns del mites socialdemòcrates sobre la immigració.
• La France compte 6.868.000 immigrés, soit 11% de la population métropolitaine
• L’immigration réduit des deux tiers la croissance du PIB
• Le coût de l’immigration en France est de 71,76 milliards d’euros
• Les recettes liées à l’immigration en France sont de 45,57 milliards d’euros
• Le déficit dû à l’immigration et supporté par les contribuables est de 26,19 milliards d’euros
• Lorsqu’une personne immigrée ne repart pas dans son pays d’origine à la fin de son contrat de travail, c’est l’Etat (le contribuable) qui prend en charge le coût des prestations sociales
• Les immigrés extra-européens et leurs descendants perçoivent 22% des prestations sociales
• Le coût unitaire des demandes d’asile est de 15.000 euros
• La plupart des dépenses d’immigration ne relèvent pas du ministère de l’Immigration de Brice Hortefeux
• Les dépenses sécuritaires liées à l’immigration s’élèvent à 5,2 milliards d’euros
• Le travail au noir concerne au minimum 500.000 personnes immigrées et représentent un manque à gagner pour l’Etat de 3,810 milliards d’euros
• 65 à 90% des prostituées sont étrangères
• Le taux de chômage des immigrés est le double de celui des non immigrés
• Les prestations sociales constituent 14% du revenu moyen des ménages immigrés contre 5% pour les ménages non immigrés

(Via Conservateur)
Si us interessa l'article de David Mamet en castellà, cliqueu aquí.

McCain encapçala els sondejos

L'últim sondeig Gallup dóna un clar avantatge a Hillary Clinton respecte Barack Obama, però sobretot mostra que el republicà John McCain guanyaria tant a Clinton com a Obama si les eleccions es féssin ara. Segons el sondeig, McCain obtindria el 47% dels vots contra el 43% d'Obama, si fos aquest el seu rival. Si pel contrari, el rival de McCain fos Hillary Clinton, la diferència seria de 48 a 45.

La guerra en les xifres

4.000 soldats nord-americans han mort a l’Iraq en cinc anys. Aquest titular l’hem vist, llegit i escoltat repetidament aquests dies com a demostració del fracàs de Bush. Però les xifres, sempre lamentables perquè darrera de cada dígit hi ha una persona, només tenen significació si es comparen amb altres xifres.

I les comparacions no avalen en cap cas la visió apocalíptica que els mitjans s’entesten a donar. Si els 4.000 soldats morts es comparen, per exemple, amb les 20.700 baixes sofertes pels insurgents armats, responsables de milers d’atemptats i crims indiscriminats, no sembla una derrota.

Fins i tot, si es comparen els gairebé 8 anys de Bush amb els 8 anys del mandat de Clinton, resulta que el saldo és encara favorable a l’adminsitració republicana, ja que durant tota l’administració demòcrata van morir 7.500 soldats nord-americans.

Si anem més enllà encara i ho comparem, com li agrada tant a la internacional mediàtica, amb la guerra del Vietnam, les dades són encara menys significatives. En els 9 anys en que els Estats Units van estar implicats directament en la guerra del sud-est asiàtic, entre 1975 i 1973, hi van morir 58.219 soldats nord-americans. És a dir, catorze vegades més.

Però de les xifres de les baixes nord-americanes a l'Iraq se’n desprenen unes altres que també val la pena publicar. Sobre tot, per confrontar-les amb alguns dels mites de l’antiamericanisme militant, com per exemple que els que més moren a les guerres dels ianquis són els negres.

El 81,5% dels 4.000 morts ho van ser en combat, mentre que el 18,5% ho van ser per accidents, malaltia, assassinat o suïcidi. El 96% dels soldats nord-americans morts eren homes. El 74,8 % eren blancs, el 10,7% llatins i el 9,5% negres.

dimarts, 18 de març del 2008

La paradoxa sexual

The New York Times fa una ressenya d’un llibre que valdrà la pena llegir: The sexual paradox, de la psicòloga i periodista Susan Pinker.

Why do girls on average lead boys for all their years in the classroom, only to fall behind in the workplace? Do girls grow up and lose their edge, while boys mature and gain theirs?

Ten years ago, no one would have thought to ask. The assumption that boys dominated at school as well as at work, while girls were silenced or ignored, seemed beyond dispute. But in her new book, “The Sexual Paradox,” a ringing salvo in the sex-difference wars, Susan Pinker stacks up the evidence of boys’ classroom woes and girls’ triumphs. “In the United States, boys are three times as likely to be placed in special education classes, twice as likely to repeat a grade and a third more likely to drop out of high school,” she writes. Tests of 15-year-olds in 30 European countries show girls far outstripping boys in reading and writing and holding their own in math. Boys are overrepresented in the top 1 percent of math achievers, but there are also more of them at the bottom. A 2006 economics study showed universities practicing affirmative action for men so that superior female applicants wouldn’t swamp them. “If you were to predict the future on the basis of school achievement alone,” Pinker writes, “the world would be a matriarchy.”

And yet, of course, it is not. Once they move from school to work, men on average earn more money and run more shows. They particularly dominate in national government, the corporate boardroom and the science laboratory. Meanwhile, women are more likely to leave the labor force and to end up with lower pay and less authority if they come back.

Pinker, a psychologist and a columnist at The Globe and Mail in Canada, is careful to remind her readers that statistics say nothing about the choices women and men make individually. Nor does she entirely discount the effect of sex discrimination or culture in shaping women’s choices. But she thinks these forces play only a bit part. To support this, Pinker quotes a female Ivy League law professor: “I am very skeptical of the notion that society discourages talented women from becoming scientists,” the professor writes. “My experience, at least from the educational phase of my life, is that the very opposite is true.” If women aren’t racing to the upper echelons of science, government and the corporate world despite decades of efforts to woo them, Pinker argues, then it must be because they are wired to resist the demands at the top of those fields.

Thus, Pinker parks herself firmly among “difference” feminists. Women’s brains aren’t inferior, she argues, but they vary considerably from men’s, and this is the primary explanation for the workplace gender divide. Women care more about intrinsic rewards, they have broader interests, they are more service-oriented and they are better at gauging the effect they have on others. They are “wired for empathy.” These aren’t learned traits; they’re the result of genes and hormones. Beginning in utero, men are generally exposed to higher levels of testosterone, driving them to be more competitive, assertive, vengeful and daring. Women, meanwhile, get a regular dose of oxytocin, which helps them read people’s emotions, “the truest social enabler.” Then there’s prolactin, which, along with oxytocin, surges during pregnancy, breast-feeding and caretaking. Together, the hormones produce such a high that mother rats choose their newborns over cocaine.

La bona salut política de Sarkozy

La premsa socialdemòcrata, que com vostès ja saben és pràcticament tota la premsa existent, ha interpretat les eleccions municipals franceses en clau exclusivament nacional per poder anunciar així la bona nova del declivi de Sarkozy i del reneixement imparable de l’esquerra. Certament, la tendència esperpèntica de l’inquil·lí d’Elisi no ha afavorit gaire el seu partit, però els francesos continuen donant suport a les promeses de canvi fetes per Sarkozy. Un sondeig CSA per a Europe1, Le Parisien, Aujourd’hui en France i iTele, fet per telèfon diumenge passat al vespre, dia de la segona volta de les eleccions municipals, no deixa lloc al dubte :

66 % "per que François Fillon continui com a primer ministre"
67 % "per que les reformes anunciades es portin a terme"
58 % "Nicolas Sarkozy ha d’esforçar-se a adoptar un estil més presidencial"
66% " seguir la lluita per millorar el poder adquisitiu"
42% " per les reformes que permetin limitar les despeses de l’Estat"

Una vegada més, els morts que maten guadeixen de bona salut.

Boicot als Jocs Olímpics de Pequín

Reporters sense Fronteres:
Ante las crecientes violaciones de los derechos humanos en China, y la sangrante falta de libertad en el país, Reporteros sin Fronteras hace un llamamiento a los jefes de Estado, jefes de gobierno y miembros de familias reales, a boicotear la ceremonia inaugural de Pekín 2008, el próximo 8 de agosto.

dilluns, 17 de març del 2008

Els iraquians, optimistes


Enquesta publicada per la BBC:
El 55% de los iraquíes considera que viven bien, según una encuesta realizada por encargo de la BBC y otras organizaciones.

El resultado indica un gran incremento en el optimismo de muchos iraquíes, en comparación con un sondeo similar llevado a cabo en agosto de 2007, cuando sólo el 39% se manifestó satisfecho.

De acuerdo a la nueva encuesta -hecha por D3 Systems y KA Research Ltd a solicitud de las corporaciones BBC del Reino Unido, ABC News de Estados Unidos, ARD de Alemania y NHK de Japón- el 62% de las 2.000 personas entrevistadas estima que la seguridad ha mejorado, en el último año, en las áreas donde viven.

Mientras que la mayoría de los iraquíes todavía creen que la presencia militar de Estados Unidos empeora las cosas, ahora es menor el número de quienes quieren que los estadounidenses salgan de Irak de forma inmediata. (...)

Sólo el 33% de los sunitas opina que viven bien, en comparación con el 62% de los chiitas y el 73% de los kurdos.

David Mamet també ha deixat de ser "progre"

Via Barcepundit m'assabento que el conegut guionista i dramaturg nord-americà, David Mamet, acaba de publicar un article en el que explica que ha deixat de ser "progre". Mamet sempre m'ha semblat un autor interessant i profund que podiem veure al cinema i, de tant en tant, en els nostres teatres. Espero que aquesta declaració no serveixi perquè la nostra faràndula progresista l'esbandeixi dels escenaris per fatxa i neocon. Com que l'article és també un delícia literària no me'n puc estar de reproduïr-lo íntegrament.


David Mamet: Why I Am No Longer a 'Brain-Dead Liberal'
An election-season essay
by David Mamet

John Maynard Keynes was twitted with changing his mind. He replied, "When the facts change, I change my opinion. What do you do, sir?"

My favorite example of a change of mind was Norman Mailer at The Village Voice.

Norman took on the role of drama critic, weighing in on the New York premiere of Waiting for Godot.

Twentieth century's greatest play. Without bothering to go, Mailer called it a piece of garbage.

When he did get around to seeing it, he realized his mistake. He was no longer a Voice columnist, however, so he bought a page in the paper and wrote a retraction, praising the play as the masterpiece it is.

Every playwright's dream.

I once won one of Mary Ann Madden's "Competitions" in New York magazine. The task was to name or create a "10" of anything, and mine was the World's Perfect Theatrical Review. It went like this: "I never understood the theater until last night. Please forgive everything I've ever written. When you read this I'll be dead." That, of course, is the only review anybody in the theater ever wants to get.

My prize, in a stunning example of irony, was a year's subscription to New York, which rag (apart from Mary Ann's "Competition") I considered an open running sore on the body of world literacy—this due to the presence in its pages of John Simon, whose stunning amalgam of superciliousness and savagery, over the years, was appreciated by that readership searching for an endorsement of proactive mediocrity.

But I digress.

-------------------------------------------------------------------

I wrote a play about politics (November, Barrymore Theater, Broadway, some seats still available). And as part of the "writing process," as I believe it's called, I started thinking about politics. This comment is not actually as jejune as it might seem. Porgy and Bess is a buncha good songs but has nothing to do with race relations, which is the flag of convenience under which it sailed.

But my play, it turned out, was actually about politics, which is to say, about the polemic between persons of two opposing views. The argument in my play is between a president who is self-interested, corrupt, suborned, and realistic, and his leftish, lesbian, utopian-socialist speechwriter.

The play, while being a laugh a minute, is, when it's at home, a disputation between reason and faith, or perhaps between the conservative (or tragic) view and the liberal (or perfectionist) view. The conservative president in the piece holds that people are each out to make a living, and the best way for government to facilitate that is to stay out of the way, as the inevitable abuses and failures of this system (free-market economics) are less than those of government intervention.

I took the liberal view for many decades, but I believe I have changed my mind.

As a child of the '60s, I accepted as an article of faith that government is corrupt, that business is exploitative, and that people are generally good at heart.

These cherished precepts had, over the years, become ingrained as increasingly impracticable prejudices. Why do I say impracticable? Because although I still held these beliefs, I no longer applied them in my life. How do I know? My wife informed me. We were riding along and listening to NPR. I felt my facial muscles tightening, and the words beginning to form in my mind: Shut the fuck up. "?" she prompted. And her terse, elegant summation, as always, awakened me to a deeper truth: I had been listening to NPR and reading various organs of national opinion for years, wonder and rage contending for pride of place. Further: I found I had been—rather charmingly, I thought—referring to myself for years as "a brain-dead liberal," and to NPR as "National Palestinian Radio."

This is, to me, the synthesis of this worldview with which I now found myself disenchanted: that everything is always wrong.

But in my life, a brief review revealed, everything was not always wrong, and neither was nor is always wrong in the community in which I live, or in my country. Further, it was not always wrong in previous communities in which I lived, and among the various and mobile classes of which I was at various times a part.

And, I wondered, how could I have spent decades thinking that I thought everything was always wrong at the same time that I thought I thought that people were basically good at heart? Which was it? I began to question what I actually thought and found that I do not think that people are basically good at heart; indeed, that view of human nature has both prompted and informed my writing for the last 40 years. I think that people, in circumstances of stress, can behave like swine, and that this, indeed, is not only a fit subject, but the only subject, of drama.

-------------------------------------------------------------

I'd observed that lust, greed, envy, sloth, and their pals are giving the world a good run for its money, but that nonetheless, people in general seem to get from day to day; and that we in the United States get from day to day under rather wonderful and privileged circumstances—that we are not and never have been the villains that some of the world and some of our citizens make us out to be, but that we are a confection of normal (greedy, lustful, duplicitous, corrupt, inspired—in short, human) individuals living under a spectacularly effective compact called the Constitution, and lucky to get it.

For the Constitution, rather than suggesting that all behave in a godlike manner, recognizes that, to the contrary, people are swine and will take any opportunity to subvert any agreement in order to pursue what they consider to be their proper interests.

To that end, the Constitution separates the power of the state into those three branches which are for most of us (I include myself) the only thing we remember from 12 years of schooling.

The Constitution, written by men with some experience of actual government, assumes that the chief executive will work to be king, the Parliament will scheme to sell off the silverware, and the judiciary will consider itself Olympian and do everything it can to much improve (destroy) the work of the other two branches. So the Constitution pits them against each other, in the attempt not to achieve stasis, but rather to allow for the constant corrections necessary to prevent one branch from getting too much power for too long.

Rather brilliant. For, in the abstract, we may envision an Olympian perfection of perfect beings in Washington doing the business of their employers, the people, but any of us who has ever been at a zoning meeting with our property at stake is aware of the urge to cut through all the pernicious bullshit and go straight to firearms.

I found not only that I didn't trust the current government (that, to me, was no surprise), but that an impartial review revealed that the faults of this president—whom I, a good liberal, considered a monster—were little different from those of a president whom I revered.

Bush got us into Iraq, JFK into Vietnam. Bush stole the election in Florida; Kennedy stole his in Chicago. Bush outed a CIA agent; Kennedy left hundreds of them to die in the surf at the Bay of Pigs. Bush lied about his military service; Kennedy accepted a Pulitzer Prize for a book written by Ted Sorenson. Bush was in bed with the Saudis, Kennedy with the Mafia. Oh.

And I began to question my hatred for "the Corporations"—the hatred of which, I found, was but the flip side of my hunger for those goods and services they provide and without which we could not live.

And I began to question my distrust of the "Bad, Bad Military" of my youth, which, I saw, was then and is now made up of those men and women who actually risk their lives to protect the rest of us from a very hostile world. Is the military always right? No. Neither is government, nor are the corporations—they are just different signposts for the particular amalgamation of our country into separate working groups, if you will. Are these groups infallible, free from the possibility of mismanagement, corruption, or crime? No, and neither are you or I. So, taking the tragic view, the question was not "Is everything perfect?" but "How could it be better, at what cost, and according to whose definition?" Put into which form, things appeared to me to be unfolding pretty well.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Do I speak as a member of the "privileged class"? If you will—but classes in the United States are mobile, not static, which is the Marxist view. That is: Immigrants came and continue to come here penniless and can (and do) become rich; the nerd makes a trillion dollars; the single mother, penniless and ignorant of English, sends her two sons to college (my grandmother). On the other hand, the rich and the children of the rich can go belly-up; the hegemony of the railroads is appropriated by the airlines, that of the networks by the Internet; and the individual may and probably will change status more than once within his lifetime.

What about the role of government? Well, in the abstract, coming from my time and background, I thought it was a rather good thing, but tallying up the ledger in those things which affect me and in those things I observe, I am hard-pressed to see an instance where the intervention of the government led to much beyond sorrow.

But if the government is not to intervene, how will we, mere human beings, work it all out?

I wondered and read, and it occurred to me that I knew the answer, and here it is: We just seem to. How do I know? From experience. I referred to my own—take away the director from the staged play and what do you get? Usually a diminution of strife, a shorter rehearsal period, and a better production.

The director, generally, does not cause strife, but his or her presence impels the actors to direct (and manufacture) claims designed to appeal to Authority—that is, to set aside the original goal (staging a play for the audience) and indulge in politics, the purpose of which may be to gain status and influence outside the ostensible goal of the endeavor.

Strand unacquainted bus travelers in the middle of the night, and what do you get? A lot of bad drama, and a shake-and-bake Mayflower Compact. Each, instantly, adds what he or she can to the solution. Why? Each wants, and in fact needs, to contribute—to throw into the pot what gifts each has in order to achieve the overall goal, as well as status in the new-formed community. And so they work it out.

See also that most magnificent of schools, the jury system, where, again, each brings nothing into the room save his or her own prejudices, and, through the course of deliberation, comes not to a perfect solution, but a solution acceptable to the community—a solution the community can live with.

Prior to the midterm elections, my rabbi was taking a lot of flack. The congregation is exclusively liberal, he is a self-described independent (read "conservative"), and he was driving the flock wild. Why? Because a) he never discussed politics; and b) he taught that the quality of political discourse must be addressed first—that Jewish law teaches that it is incumbent upon each person to hear the other fellow out.

And so I, like many of the liberal congregation, began, teeth grinding, to attempt to do so. And in doing so, I recognized that I held those two views of America (politics, government, corporations, the military). One was of a state where everything was magically wrong and must be immediately corrected at any cost; and the other—the world in which I actually functioned day to day—was made up of people, most of whom were reasonably trying to maximize their comfort by getting along with each other (in the workplace, the marketplace, the jury room, on the freeway, even at the school-board meeting).

And I realized that the time had come for me to avow my participation in that America in which I chose to live, and that that country was not a schoolroom teaching values, but a marketplace.

--------------------------------------------------------------

"Aha," you will say, and you are right. I began reading not only the economics of Thomas Sowell (our greatest contemporary philosopher) but Milton Friedman, Paul Johnson, and Shelby Steele, and a host of conservative writers, and found that I agreed with them: a free-market understanding of the world meshes more perfectly with my experience than that idealistic vision I called liberalism.

At the same time, I was writing my play about a president, corrupt, venal, cunning, and vengeful (as I assume all of them are), and two turkeys. And I gave this fictional president a speechwriter who, in his view, is a "brain-dead liberal," much like my earlier self; and in the course of the play, they have to work it out. And they eventually do come to a human understanding of the political process. As I believe I am trying to do, and in which I believe I may be succeeding, and I will try to summarize it in the words of William Allen White.

White was for 40 years the editor of the Emporia Gazette in rural Kansas, and a prominent and powerful political commentator. He was a great friend of Theodore Roosevelt and wrote the best book I've ever read about the presidency. It's called Masks in a Pageant, and it profiles presidents from McKinley to Wilson, and I recommend it unreservedly.

White was a pretty clear-headed man, and he'd seen human nature as few can. (As Twain wrote, you want to understand men, run a country paper.) White knew that people need both to get ahead and to get along, and that they're always working at one or the other, and that government should most probably stay out of the way and let them get on with it. But, he added, there is such a thing as liberalism, and it may be reduced to these saddest of words: " . . . and yet . . . "

The right is mooing about faith, the left is mooing about change, and many are incensed about the fools on the other side—but, at the end of the day, they are the same folks we meet at the water cooler. Happy election season.


diumenge, 16 de març del 2008

Vint anys de la massacre de Halabja



Avui fa vint anys de la massacre de Halabja. El 16 de març de 1988, uns 5.000 civils kurds, el 70% dels quela dones i nens, van ser atacats amb armes químiques per odre de Saddam Hussein. Els principals mitjans de comunicació de tot el món no se’n han enrecordat. Ni una línia. Pel contrari, dijous vinent tots parlaran del cinquè aniversari de la guerra de l’Iraq. I ho faran no per recordar el derrocament del genocida de Saddam Hussein, sinó per denunciar, per enèsima vegada, un “criminal” anomenat Geroge W. B ush.

divendres, 14 de març del 2008

La filosofia del periodisme en un titular

El diari El País, en la seva edició digital, publica avui aquest titular: 197.000 hombres están denunciados en España por maltrato a su pareja. Un titular que sorprèn i escandalitza perquè són molts, certament. Però si el titular digués: El 0,9 % de los hombres están denunciados en España por maltrato a su pareja, l’efecte seria més aviat el contrari, tot i que les xifres dels dos titulars siguin igual de certes. Vet aquí la filosofia del periodisme resumida en un titular.

Esquerda Republicana de Catalunya

Escoltat avui a la ràdio: L'Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya ja és només l'Esquerda Republicana de Catalunya.

dijous, 13 de març del 2008

Psicoanàlisi postelectoral

Fernando Savater:
El otro lema digno de ser psicoanalizado es el del PSE: ‘No es lo mismo’. Evidentemente, se refieren sin nombrarlo al PP para distanciarse de él ante los votantes del terruño: por muy constitucionalistas que nos consideréis, aunque no seamos nacionalistas (sólo vasquistas, que es algo así como el nacionalismo del tímido), que no nos vayan a confundir con esos españolistas retrógrados. Por supuesto, el PSE y el PP no son lo mismo en gran parte de sus propuestas, ni tienen por qué serlo. Se trata de formaciones diferentes y, aunque los conceptos de izquierda y derecha estén bastante devaluados, todavía sirven taxonómicamente para algo. Pero lo malo del lema es que parece referirse al PP como si fuera un enemigo semejante al que representa ANV o la propia ETA: no somos semejantes ni a unos ni a otros aunque hagamos más esfuerzos por entendernos con unos que con otros. Los bochornosos sucesos ocurridos en Arrasate cuando llegaron al velatorio de Isaías Carrasco Rajoy y María San Gil apuntan en esa dirección. Parece mentira que socialistas que padecieron algo semejante en el velatorio de Fernando Buesa por parte de los nacionalistas hayan podido cometer semejante indignidad. Que en el entierro de un asesinado por ETA (lo fue cobardemente, pero no insistamos ridículamente en ello: si le hubieran matado ‘heroicamente’, el crimen habría sido lo mismo de execrable) se reciba mejor a la gente de Ezker Batua, cómplices políticos en el Ayuntamiento de ANV y contrarios a ‘ilegalizar las ideas’ de aquéllos cuya idea es matar a los adversarios, que a gente como María San Gil, demuestra una pérdida de sentido moral notable por parte de los muy votados socialistas. Se resentían de antiguas ofensas, pero no fueron tan quisquillosos cuando se reunieron con Otegi y compañía, que también les habían dedicado numerosos calificativos poco halagadores en el pasado.

No tengo inconveniente en reconocer que, incluso algunos de quienes tienen tan poca simpatía como yo por la actual directiva del PSE (menos lo creo imposible), hemos celebrado los resultados electorales que certifican el declive nacionalista. Ahora sería excelente un punto de acuerdo entre socialistas y populares en lo tocante a la recuperación de las atribuciones del Estado de Derecho español en el País Vasco. Porque, por mucho que les moleste reconocerlo, para ETA -que es la que más cuenta en este caso- los socialistas y los populares (o cualquier otro de los que no apoyan su pretensiones) sí son lo mismo.

Comença a Cuba la via xinesa al capitalisme?

Cuba autoritza la venda lliure d'ordinadors, DVD, televisors i altres aparells electrònics.
HAVANA, March 13 (Reuters) - Communist Cuba has authorized the unrestricted sale of computers, DVD and video players and other appliances in the first sign President Raul Castro is moving to improve access to consumer goods for Cubans.
"Based on the improved availability of electricity, the government at the highest level has approved the sale of some equipment which was prohibited," said an internal government memo seen by Reuters on Thursday.
It listed computers, video and DVD players, 19-inch (48-cm) and 24-inch (61-cm) television sets, electric pressure cookers and rice cookers, electric bicycles, car alarms and microwaves that Cubans will now be allowed to buy.
Raul Castro, 76, has led Cuba since July 2006 when his older brother Fidel Castro provisionally handed over power after intestinal surgery from which he has never fully recovered.
The younger Castro formally became Cuba's first new leader in almost half a century on Feb. 24, and promised to ease some of the restrictions on daily life in Cuba.
"The country's priority will be to meet the basic needs of the population, both material and spiritual," Raul Castro said as he replaced Fidel Castro, a staunch critic of capitalist consumer society.
Last year, under Raul Castro's provisional government, customs regulations were eased to allow Cubans to bring in some electronic equipment and car parts.